SIGAda Submission
Sujet :
SIGAda Submission
De :
Baird Leemon C III LtCol USAFA/DFCS <Leemon.Baird@usafa.edu>
Date :
13/07/2007, 23:09
Pour :
"singhoff@univ-brest.fr" <singhoff@univ-brest.fr>

Frank Singhoff,

 

I am pleased to inform you that your paper has been accepted for SIGAda 2007.  The reviewers’ comments are included below.  You will receive an email from the publisher with details of how and when to submit the final version of the paper.  Please remember to register for the conference, since we won’t be able to publish papers in the proceedings for those who don’t register.  I’ll look forward to seeing you in November,

 

-----------------------------------------------

Lt Col Leemon Baird, PhD

Associate Professor and Director of Research

Department of Computer Science

US Air Force Academy

(719)333-8321

-----------------------------------------------

 

1. Paper Number: 4

2. Paper Title: AADL modeling and analysis of hierarchical schedulers

 

4. Recommendation:

            [X] Accept as is

            [] Accept with changes

            [] Do not accept

 

 

5. Comments for the author(s):

 

Interesting paper, addressing several hot topics: scheduling, AADL, ARINC653,

while showing an interesting free tool (Cheddar).

 

Paper is easy to read dispite the quite technical topic.

 

===========================================

 

1. Paper Number: 4

2. Paper Title: AADL modeling and analysis of hierarchical schedulers

 

4. Recommendation:

            [X] Accept as is

            [] Accept with changes

            [] Do not accept

 

 

5. Comments for the author(s):

 

I liked this paper.  It did a good job of describing an interesting system.  I'll look forward to seeing it 
with those two sections expanded.

 

===========================================

 

1. Paper Number: 4

2. Paper Title: AADL modeling and analysis of hierarchical schedulers

 

4. Recommendation:

            [] Accept as is

            [X] Accept with changes

            [] Do not accept

 

 

5. Comments for the author(s):

 

- Great paper!

- Simple comment:  Captialize the title --> AADL Modeling and Analysis...

- Good contribution